Closed-Loop Life Support: Why Resupply Stops Working Beyond Low Earth Orbit
An open-loop life support system carries what the crew will use and discards or stores the waste. A closed-loop system recovers resources from that waste and uses them again. Real systems sit somewhere between the two, closing some loops and leaving others open.
Why this decision depends on distance
The ISS has been continuously crewed for more than 20 years, but cargo arrives every few months. NASA engineers note that the longest gap between resupply flights has been a little over 100 days. The longest crewed mission without cargo resupply was 182 days, on China's Shenzhou 13.
A human Mars mission has no on-demand resupply at all. Everything must be carried or pre-staged. NASA studies treat this as a major driver of the system design.
What closing a loop gives you, and what it costs
Closing a loop saves consumable mass over time, but it adds hardware, power, maintenance and new ways to fail. So the right amount of closure depends on the mission. NASA's Mars study proposes closed-loop technologies for a transit habitat, while a surface habitat might use open loop, closed loop or a mix.
The reliability problem
NASA's exploration white paper makes the point plainly: a mission beyond low Earth orbit needs either a highly reliable system or thousands of pounds of spare parts. Testing on the ISS has already reduced the spares mass estimated for a Mars mission by more than 35 percent, and NASA says it is still learning after more than 14 years of regenerative operation.
Communication delay adds to this. Ground teams cannot talk a Mars crew through a repair in real time, so maintainability becomes a design requirement.
What this means for a new program
A program without decades of flight data has to find these couplings some other way. That is the reasoning behind physics-based modeling early in design: to test an architecture and its assumptions before hardware exists, then correct the model with measured data as it becomes available.